Read This Before You License That Pop Song!
Jingles vs. licensed pop songs: which is more effective for ads? Our guide helps marketers weigh the pros and cons of custom music vs. licensing a hit song for their brand.
Jingles were once everywhere. Brands used them left and right. People would get them stuck in their head on repeat all the time. There is so much we can learn from the craft of building a great jingle. But licensing a hit pop-song brings a hard to copy cultural association. Which should you use for your own ads? What if you make music and want to get into this game? Which method is better? Read on to learn more.
But first, let’s find out what’s happening in the industry.
GenAI Divides the Music Industry. What’s new?
AI generated music divides the industry. This is expected. Musicians spend their lives practicing a craft like composition only to compete with a computer with the ability to do the same at hyper speed. Where this all leads, we don’t know yet. Many people have opinions about the outcome though.
AI Slop is starting up the charts.
Continuing on the AI train, Billboard magazine makes the claim an AI generated artist is charting every week. There is, of course, a backlash from artists, but my prediction is this train will keep running. Artist’s can complain all they want, but what happens when the people listening to music don’t care if it’s AI slop or not?
Learn more about AI charting artists.
Read This Before Your Next Client Pitch! Decoding the Creative Brief.
Client briefs can be hard to understand. What do you do when a client sends you a creative brief full of marketing buzzwords? What do ‘innovative,’ ‘human-centric,’ and ‘trustworthy’ sound like? Successful composers are expert translators who can turn brand values into music. Read on to learn more.
Which of the following is more effective? The nostalgic chime of “Folgers in your cup,” or the burst of indie-cool from Feist’s “1234” in an iPod ad?
The choice of music is one of the most critical decisions in an advertising campaign. And it often boils down to one fundamental question. Do you build your own sonic identity with a jingle or license a pop song?
Licensing hit songs was the dominant strategy in the 2000s. A way to signal cultural relevance. Now brands want to focus on building ownable assets instead of licensing pop songs. Now, the jingle, plus its cousin, the sonic logo, are making a comeback.
So, which is the right move? The answer depends on your brand, your budget, and your long-term goals. Let’s break down the strategic pros and cons of each.
The Case for the Licensed Pop Song: The Emotional Shortcut
A licensed pop song is a powerful tool. Licensing a piece of music is a pre-packaged bundle of cultural associations.
The Pros:
Instant Emotional Transfer. A song can make an audience feel energized or nostalgic. You can borrow these feelings. This is a shortcut to emotional resonance.
Piggybacking on Popularity. A song from a popular artist taps into a pre-built fanbase. This is a way to signal relevance.
High Production Value. Professionals have spent time and energy producing a high quality hit song.
The Cons:
Massive Cost: Licensing a well-known song can be expensive. Fees for a national campaign can run into the six-figure or even seven-figure range.
The “Vampire Effect”: This is the biggest risk. The song is so popular that it overshadows the brand. Viewers remember the song, but they have no idea what the ad was for. The “star” of the ad becomes the music, not the product.
Limited Usage & Terms: You are only renting the song. The license will have a strict term (e..g, 1 year), territory (e.g., North America only), and media (e.g., TV and web only). If you want to renew or expand, you have to pay all over again.
Brand Risk: The artist you license from is human. Any public scandal or negative association can transfer to your brand by proxy.
The Case for the Jingle: The Long-Term Brand Asset
A jingle is a piece of music custom-built to be an “earworm” and linked to your brand name and slogan.
The Pros:
100% Ownable: This is its greatest strength. Once you create it, it is your asset forever. No competitor can use it. It becomes a core part of your brand identity, like your visual logo.
High Recall: Jingles are simple, repetitive, and catchy. Their entire purpose is to stick in your head, ensuring you remember the brand name and its key benefit. For example: “Nationwide is on your side”.
Cost-Effective in the Long Run: While there is an upfront creation fee, you pay it once. You never have to re-license your own jingle, giving it an incredible long-term ROI.
Brand-Specific: The lyrics can communicate your brand’s name, slogan, or unique selling proposition.
The Cons:
The “Cringe Factor”: If not produced well, jingles can feel dated, “cheesy,” or low-budget. A bad jingle can make a brand feel old-fashioned or cheap.
Takes Time to Build Equity: A jingle has no pre-existing emotional connection in the public’s mind. Your brand must spend significant time and ad dollars to build that association.
The Modern Solution: The Custom Score & Sonic Logo
Today, the “jingle vs. licensed song” debate is a bit of a false choice. Successful modern brands opt for a hybrid third option: the custom-scored track and the sonic logo.
The Custom Score: This is a piece of music in the style of a pop, electronic, or orchestral track, but written for the ad. It gives all the emotional power and high production value of a “real song”. And none of the high licensing fees or the “vampire effect.” It is unique and yours; crafted to hit the emotional beats of the ad.
The Sonic Logo (The Modern Jingle): This is the jingle’s more sophisticated cousin. It’s a short, melodic sound (think Netflix’s “ta-dum” or Intel’s “bong”) that acts as your brand’s signature. It’s less intrusive than a full-on jingle but as ownable and memorable.
The Verdict?
Choose a Licensed Pop Song if... you have a massive budget and need to make an instant cultural splash. Your goal is to align your brand with a specific artist’s identity (e.g., Apple).
Choose a Jingle if... your focus is on long-term brand recall with an ownable, high-ROI asset. Think insurance, CPG, or local service brands.
Choose a Custom Score if... you want the best of both worlds. The emotional impact of a pop song and the ownability of a jingle, all for a fraction of the cost.
The goal isn’t only to find music for your ad; it’s to find the music that is your brand.
Need help finding background music that boosts engagement? 🎧 Explore our licensing catalog or work with Playbutton Media to get custom-curated music tailored to your content goals.